After a deep investigation into the n=5 mecanum sim-to-real gap, all
attempted fixes (consensus tightening, wall_reject tightening, static-
phantom drop, deploy-time track merge, in-tracker track merge,
fp_rate-augmented retrain, max_range cap, 140° mecanum retrain) failed
to reliably pen n=5 in Webots without regressing n=10. The phantom
problem at 360° + small flock is genuinely hard and out of scope for
the deadline; documented in docs/status.md.
Result preserved from the previous mecanum work:
* 16/16 differential cells pen N/N.
* 4/8 mecanum cells (all n=10) pen 10/10 via Supervisor kinematic
injection (commit 27c0f65).
* n=5 mecanum is the known gap.
Small changes that survived the iteration:
* tests/test_config.py — strafe_efficiency=1.0 is now valid (kinematic
injection means the gym preset and Webots controller share the
formula, so textbook values produce gym-identical body motion).
* tools/run_webots.sh — refreshed the LiDAR-variant comment.
* training/rl/train.py — comment polish.
Training and evaluation details
Command-level companion to the root README. Covers demo collection, behaviour cloning, PPO fine-tuning, and evaluation flags; use the root README for the high-level architecture and Webots quick start.
The pipeline is two strictly-sequential stages per (drive, world)
combo:
sim demos (universal teacher on tracker output, K=4 frame stack)
│
▼
bc/pretrain.py ──► runs/bc_<drive>_<world> (MLP)
│
▼ KL-regularised PPO fine-tune
│
runs/rl_<drive>_<world> (deployed `rl` mode)
Files
herding_env.py — Gymnasium env (LiDAR raycast + tracker by default)
bc/collect.py — universal-teacher sim demos
bc/pretrain.py — MSE + cosine BC of (obs, action) demos into MlpPolicy
rl/train.py — KL-regularised PPO fine-tune of a BC checkpoint
rl/train_lstm.py — RecurrentPPO variant (ablation)
eval.py — multi-seed analytic / learned policy comparison
runs/ — checkpoints (gitignored except for policy.zip)
Unit + integration tests live in the top-level tests/. Run with
make test or python -m pytest tests/.
End-to-end pipeline
The simplest way to train one combo is the project-root Makefile:
make DRIVE=differential WORLD=field # demos → bc → rl → eval
make DRIVE=differential WORLD=field_round
make train_all # all four combos sequentially
The individual stages below are kept explicit for cases where you want to tune a single step.
# 1. Sim demos with the active-scan + universal teacher under LiDAR
# perception. K=4 frame stack so the MLP has temporal context.
python -m training.bc.collect \
--teacher universal --drive-mode differential --world field \
--out training/bc/demos_differential_field.npz \
--seeds-per-n 15 --subsample 3 --frame-stack 4
# 2. Behaviour-clone the demos.
python -m training.bc.pretrain \
--demos training/bc/demos_differential_field.npz \
--out training/runs/bc_differential_field \
--epochs 60 --net-arch 512,512
# 3. KL-regularised PPO fine-tune of bc.
python -m training.rl.train \
--bc training/runs/bc_differential_field \
--out training/runs/rl_differential_field \
--drive-mode differential --world field \
--total-timesteps 1000000
# 4. Multi-seed eval (env-side, fast).
python -m training.eval --policy training/runs/rl_differential_field \
--drive-mode differential --world field \
--max-flock 10 --max-steps 15000 --n-seeds 10
bc/pretrain.py saves the best-val_cos snapshot, not the final
epoch — multi-modal teachers make training noisy and the last epoch
is often worse than an earlier one.
rl/train.py loads BC weights into both a trainable policy and a
frozen reference, fixes log_std small, and adds β · KL(π‖π_ref) to
the loss so the policy can only move within a trust region around BC.
See the file header for hyperparameter rationale.
Mecanum retraining
For mecanum runs, pass --use-webots-preset. Both collect.py and
train.py detect --drive-mode mecanum and switch to the
HERDING_MEC_WEBOTS preset, which matches the physical-roller
Webots proto's strafe efficiency (0.4) and forward bleed (−0.28).
Training without this preset produces a policy that herds in textbook
gym mecanum but not in Webots.
Analytic teachers
| Name | What it does | Notes |
|---|---|---|
strombom |
Strömbom 2014 — collect when flock is scattered, drive CoM otherwise | Round-world aware (radially-inward fallback when natural target lies outside the curved boundary) |
sequential |
Three-phase: collect, drive, then single-target push for the last 1–2 stragglers | Alternative to strombom |
universal |
Strömbom core + mecanum omega + last-straggler recovery | Used as the BC demo teacher |
All three are wrapped at demo-collection time in
herding/control/active_scan.py:ActiveScanTeacher, which adds an
opening in-place rotation, walk-to-centre when the LiDAR sees
nothing, and near-sheep speed modulation (same modulation
herding/control/modulation.py applies to every dog mode at
inference).
Evaluating analytic teachers directly
python -m training.eval --policy strombom \
--drive-mode differential --world field \
--max-flock 10 --max-steps 15000 --n-seeds 10
python -m training.eval --policy sequential \
--drive-mode differential --world field_round \
--max-flock 10 --max-steps 15000 --n-seeds 10