Adds RecurrentPPO-based training as an alternative to MLP+frame-stack. The LSTM gives the policy unbounded temporal memory, addressing the partial-obs failure mode of the 140° Webots LiDAR (tracker briefly empties when the dog turns; sporadic phantom tracks confuse decisions). * training/rl/train_lstm.py: from-scratch RecurrentPPO trainer (no BC init, no KL term since there's no reference). Uses HERDING_WEBOTS preset so the obs distribution matches deployment. * training/eval.py: auto-detects RecurrentPPO zips, maintains LSTM hidden state across steps, resets between episodes. * controllers/shepherd_dog/policy_loader.py: PolicyHandle supports recurrent policies — state managed inside, reset_recurrent() exposed. Result on diff/field after 3M steps: - Gym (default 360°): 69% avg success across n=1..10 - Gym (HERDING_WEBOTS preset, training env): 2% — penning 3-4/5 but rarely all 5 - Webots LiDAR 140°: 0/5 (same wall as DAgger and v1 policies) Conclusion: architectural changes (LSTM vs MLP) don't close the perception sim-to-real gap. The gym LiDAR sim doesn't faithfully reproduce Webots phantom-track distribution; any policy trained on the gym proxy fails to handle real Webots phantoms regardless of architecture. Closing this gap requires either modeling Webots phantom patterns in the gym sim (multi-day work) or Webots-in-the-loop training (very slow). See memory/lstm_results.md for details. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Training and Evaluation Details
This file is the command-level companion to the root README. It focuses on data collection, BC, PPO fine-tuning, evaluation flags, and generated artifacts; use the root README for the high-level architecture and Webots demo quick start.
Two stages, strictly sequential:
sim demos (Strömbom on tracker output, K=4 frame stack)
│
▼
bc/pretrain.py ──► runs/bc (Strömbom-imitated MLP)
│
▼ KL-regularised PPO fine-tune
│
runs/rl (deployed `rl` mode — beats BC and Strömbom)
Files
herding_env.py — Gymnasium env (LiDAR raycast + tracker by default)
bc/pretrain.py — MSE + cosine BC of (obs, action) demos into MlpPolicy
rl/train.py — KL-regularised PPO fine-tune of a BC checkpoint
eval.py — multi-seed analytic / learned policy comparison
runs/ — checkpoints (whitelisted entries in top-level .gitignore)
(Unit + integration tests live in the top-level ``tests/`` directory;
run with ``python -m pytest tests/``.)
End-to-end pipeline
The simplest way to run everything is the Makefile at the project
root: make does the full chain, make rl rebuilds whatever's
needed up to that point, etc. The individual stages below are kept
explicit for cases where you want to tune a single step.
# 1. Sim demos with the active-scan + Strömbom teacher under LiDAR
# perception. K=4 frame stack so the MLP has temporal context.
python -m training.bc.collect --teacher strombom \
--out training/bc/demos.npz --seeds-per-n 15 --subsample 3 --frame-stack 4
# 2. Behaviour-clone.
python -m training.bc.pretrain --demos training/bc/demos.npz \
--out training/runs/bc --epochs 60 --net-arch 512,512
# 3. KL-regularised PPO fine-tune of bc.
python -m training.rl.train \
--bc training/runs/bc --out training/runs/rl \
--total-timesteps 1000000
# 4. Multi-seed eval (env-side, fast).
python -m training.eval --policy training/runs/rl \
--max-flock 10 --max-steps 15000 --n-seeds 10
bc/pretrain.py saves the best-val_cos snapshot, not the final
epoch — multi-modal teachers make training noisy and the last epoch is
often worse than an earlier one.
rl/train.py loads BC weights into both a trainable policy and a
frozen reference, fixes log_std small, and adds β · KL(π‖π_ref) to
the loss so the policy can only move within a trust region around BC.
See the file header for hyperparameter rationale.
Available analytic teachers
| Name | What it does | Notes |
|---|---|---|
strombom |
Strömbom 2014 — collect when flock is scattered, drive CoM otherwise | Default; works for n=1–10 under tight cohesion |
sequential |
Pick the sheep closest to the pen and drive only it | Alternative; needs loose-cohesion regime |
Both are wrapped at demo-collection time in
herding/control/active_scan.py:ActiveScanTeacher, which adds an
opening in-place rotation, walk-to-centre when the LiDAR sees
nothing, and near-sheep speed modulation (same modulation
herding/control/modulation.py applies to every dog mode at
inference).
Evaluating analytic teachers directly
python -m training.eval --policy strombom --max-flock 10 --max-steps 15000 --n-seeds 10
python -m training.eval --policy sequential --max-flock 10 --max-steps 15000 --n-seeds 10